收稿日期: 2020-07-25
修回日期: 2020-09-27
网络出版日期: 2021-05-28
基金资助
江西省教育厅科学技术研究项目“基于绿色度的离子型稀土资源开发与生态修复一体化技术研究”(GJJ200842);江西理工大学繁荣哲学社会科学项目“离子型稀土资源开发负外部性及其生态补偿机制研究”(FZ18-YB-09)
Analysis of the Influential Factors on the Treatment Effect of Abandoned Rare Earth Mine Based on ISM and ANP
Received date: 2020-07-25
Revised date: 2020-09-27
Online published: 2021-05-28
为系统了解关键因素对废弃稀土矿山治理效果的影响机理,从自然禀赋、矿业活动、环境污染、土地资源脆弱程度、景观生态、治理工程、管理技术和政策响应8个方面构建了废弃稀土矿山治理效果影响因素指标体系。基于解释结构模型(ISM)和网络层次分析模型(ANP),研究各指标间的相互影响关系,找到影响废弃稀土矿山治理效果的主要因素,为今后开展废弃稀土矿山治理工作提供科学建议。研究结果表明:(1)废弃稀土矿山治理效果影响因素指标体系是具有10级递阶结构的复杂系统,可划分为表层直接影响因素、中间层间接影响因素和深层根本影响因素3个层级;(2)开采面积、主要开采方式、建矿时间、植被覆盖度、水土流失面积比和土地复垦工程所占权重较大,是影响废弃稀土矿山治理效果的主要因素。基于研究结果,认为联络线工程和工作督查在我国废弃稀土矿山治理工作中起着关键性作用,同时应加强对稀土开采的源头管控,注重对废弃稀土矿区土地资源的修复,推动废弃稀土矿山治理效果的提升。
关键词: 废弃稀土矿山; 治理效果; 解释结构模型(ISM); 网络层次分析法(ANP); 影响因素; 指标体系; 绿色发展
黄锴强 , 徐水太 , 薛飞 . 基于ISM和ANP的废弃稀土矿山治理效果影响因素分析[J]. 黄金科学技术, 2021 , 29(2) : 306 -314 . DOI: 10.11872/j.issn.1005-2518.2021.02.136
Rare earth elements are widely used in China’s industry and agriculture.They are important non renewable resources and are known as “industrial vitamins”.In recent years,with the rapid development of China’s economy and society,the demand for rare earth is also increasing.In pursuit of economic benefits,rare earth mining has left many abandoned rare earth mines.The serious damage of surface vegetation has led to serious environmental problems such as soil erosion and debris flow,which has gradually attracted the attention of the state and all walks of life.In order to understand the key factors that affect the governance effect of abandoned rare earth mines,provide scientific advice for the development of the governance of abandoned rare earth mines,this paper carried out research on the factors affecting the governance effect of abandoned rare earth mines. In the aspects of natural endowment,mining activities,environmental pollution,vulnerability of land resources,landscape ecology,treatment engineering,management technology and policy response,the influencing factors index system had been built to analyze treatment effect of abandoned rare earth mine.Based on the interpretative structural model (ISM),the direct influence relationship between indicators was analyzed,and the hierarchical structure of influencing factors was constructed.The influence of each index on the treatment effect of abandoned rare earth mine was analyzed from three aspects of impact factor,middle indirect influence factor and deep fundamental influence factor.Then,the relationship between the indicators had been put forward to build analytic hierarchy process model (ANP).And the main index factors of abandoned rare earth mine governance were found by calculating the weight influencing factors.The results show that the index system of influencing factors on the treatment effect of abandoned rare earth mines can be divided into complex system with 10 levels of hierarchical structure,which can be divided into three levels:Direct influencing factors of surface layer,indirect influencing factors of intermediate layer and fundamental influencing factors of deep layer.Mining area,main mining methods,mining time, mining activities,area ratio of soil and water loss under landscape ecology,and treatment project accounted for more than 0.05,which were the main factors affecting the treatment effect of abandoned rare earth mines.Based on the research results,the tie line project and work supervision are located in the key position of the hierarchical structure model,connecting the preceding with the following,playing an important connectivity role in the governance work,which needs the management department to pay more attention to.The mining activities and landscape ecological criteria layer occupy the largest weight among all the criteria layers,so the regulatory authorities should strengthen the supervision of rare earth mining and land resources damage,do a good job in source control,and pay attention to the restoration of land resources in abandoned rare earth mining areas,so as to prevent the further deterioration of environmental problems of abandoned rare earth mines and accelerate the green development of abandoned rare earth mines.
null | Chen Min,Zhang Dachao,Zhu Qingjiang,al et,2017.Ionic rare earth mine of abandoned land of ecological restoration of research progress[J].Journal of the Chinese Society of Rare Earths,35(4):461-468. |
null | Geng Yangdan,Zhang Shuiping,Ding Yuanchun,2018.Evaluation of emergency capacity of urban gas pipeline based on ANP-BP[J].Journal of Jiangxi University of Science and Technology,39(3):63-68. |
null | Guo wei,Fu Ruiying,Zhao Renxin,al et,2014.Eco-environmental contaminations caused by the rare earth mining and the related controlling measures[J].Journal of Safety and Environment,14(5):245-251. |
null | Guo Zhongqun,Zhao Kui,Jin Jiefang,al et,2019.Reviews on environmental assessment and pollution prevention of ion adsorption type rare earth ores[J].Chinese Rare Earths,40(3):115-126. |
null | Jin Shulan,Huang Yizong,2013.A review on rare earth elements in farmland ecosystem[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,33(16):4836-4845. |
null | Li Haidong,Gao Yuanyun,Yan Shouguang,2018.Supervisory countermeasures of ecological restoration of abandoned mine areas in the ecological conservation redline area[J].Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment,34(8):673-677. |
null | Li Zonghuo,Liu Meilian,2017.Analysis of the influential factors on the low-carbon development of logistics enterprises based on ISM and ANP[J].Chinese Journal of Systems Science,25(4):105-109. |
null | Liao Zhennan,He Wen,Liu Hongxing,al et,2014.Quality assessment of geological environment of ion-absorbed rare-earth mine in Longnan County[J].Nonferrous Metals Science and Engineering,5(4):106-111. |
null | Liu Xiangmin,Lin Yanhua,Hou Bing,al et,2018.Research on incentive measures of mining wasteland comprehensive governance based on the revenue and distribution of governance results[J].China Mining Magazine,27(4):96-101. |
null | Liu Yiqing,Liang Yanru,2019.Research on operation mechanism of PPP mode in mine wasteland management based on evolutionary simulation analysis[J].China Mining Magazine,28(9):59-66. |
null | Peng Yan,He Guojin,Zhang Zhaoming,al et,2016.Eco-environmental dynamic monitoring and assessment of rare earth mining area in Southern Ganzhou using remote sensing[J].Acta Ecologica Sinica,36(6):1676-1685. |
null | Shi Xiaoyan,Chen Hongwen,2019.Contamination and restoration of abandoned pool and heap leaching sites of rare earth mine[J].Journal of the Chinese Society of Rare Earths,37(4):409-417. |
null | Su Junde,2018.A study on vegetation carbon storage in ecological restoration area of abandoned mines[J].Bulletin of Soil and Water Conservation,38(5):234-237. |
null | Wang Meiqi,Yang Jianying,Sun Yongkang,al et,2020.Remote sensing rapid extraction technology for abandoned mine vegetation coverage via UAV[J].Science of Soil and Water Conservation,18(2):130-139. |
null | Warfield J N,1973.On arranging elements of a hierarchy in graphic form[J].IEEE Transactions on Systems Man & Cybernetics,SMC-3(2):121-132. |
null | Wei Zhenya,Luo Xianping,Liang Jian,al et,2018.Research progress of ecological restoration of abandoned land in southern rare earth mine[J].Nonferrous Metals Science and Engineering,9(4):102-106. |
null | Wu Zebin,Wu Lijun,Lu Jinghong,al et,2018.Research on public participation willingness and influencing factors in ecological rehabilitation of abandoned rare earth mines in Southern Jiangxi[J].Journal of Jiangxi University of Science and Technology,39(4):47-51. |
null | Xing Baojun,Tang Shuiqing,Li Naiwen,al et,2017.Model of influencing factors for safety attention attenuation of miners with ISM coupling ANP[J].Journal of Safety Science and Technology,13(9):163-168. |
null | Xu Ligang,Wang Yuxin,Guan Jingwen,2019.Negative externality feedback mechanism of rare earth resource development from the perspective of industrial chain security[J].Gold Science and Technology,27(4):609-620. |
null | Xu Shuitai,2014.Problems and countermeasures of sustainable development of rare earth industry in Ganzhou[J].Journal of Jiangxi University of Science and Technology,35(4):47-51. |
null | Xu Shuitai,Xiang Yu,Liu Zhongya,2016.Simulation and predication of ammonia nitrogen contamination of groundwater in ionic adsorption rare earth in-situ leaching mining[J].Nonferrous Metals Science and Engineering,7(2):140-146. |
null | Xu Shuitai,Zhang Hanqing,Xu Chenchen,al et,2018.Study on ecological safety evaluation of ionic rare earth mining area based on PSR model[J].Science and Technology Management Research,(15):263-267. |
null | Yu Yang,Wang Denghong,Tian Zhaoxue,al et,2017.Establishment and application of SMAIMA working method system and environment evaluation model for rare earth elements mine:A case study of ion-absorption type REE mines in Southern Jiangxi Province[J].Acta Geoscientica Sinica,38(3):335-344. |
null | Zheng Xiankun,Feng Xiujuan,Chen Zhe,al et,2019.Research progress on environmental problems of ionic rare earth mining and restoration of abandoned land[J].Applied Che-mical Industry,48(3):681-684. |
null | 陈敏,张大超,朱清江,等,2017.离子型稀土矿山废弃地生态修复研究进展[J].中国稀土学报,35(4):461-468. |
null | 耿阳丹,张水平,丁元春,2018.基于ANP-BP城市燃气管道突发事件应急能力评价[J].江西理工大学学报,39(3):63-68. |
null | 郭伟,付瑞英,赵仁鑫,等,2014.稀土开发导致的环境问题及土壤稀土污染治理措施初探[J].安全与环境学报,14(5):245-251. |
null | 郭钟群,赵奎,金解放,等,2019.离子型稀土矿环境风险评估及污染治理研究进展[J].稀土,40(3):115-126. |
null | 金姝兰,黄益宗,2013.稀土元素对农田生态系统的影响研究进展[J].生态学报,33(16):4836-4845. |
null | 李海东,高媛赟,燕守广,2018.生态保护红线区废弃矿山生态修复监管[J].生态与农村环境学报,34(8):673-677. |
null | 李宗活,刘枚莲,2017.基于ISM和ANP的物流企业低碳发展影响要素分析[J].系统科学学报,25(4):105-109. |
null | 廖振楠,何文,刘洪兴,等,2014.龙南离子型稀土矿山地质环境质量评估研究[J].有色金属科学与工程,5(4):106-111. |
null | 刘向敏,林燕华,侯冰,等,2018.基于成果收益分配的矿山废弃地综合治理激励措施研究[J].中国矿业,27(4):96-101. |
null | 刘亦晴,梁雁茹,2019.基于演化仿真分析的矿山废弃地治理PPP模式运行机理研究[J].中国矿业,28(9):59-66. |
null | 彭燕,何国金,张兆明,等,2016.赣南稀土矿开发区生态环境遥感动态监测与评估[J].生态学报,36(6):1676-1685. |
null | 史晓燕,陈宏文,2019.离子型稀土矿山废弃地生态修复研究进展[J].中国稀土学报,37(4):409-417. |
null | 苏军德,2018.矿山废弃地生态修复区植被碳库研究[J].水土保持通报,38(5):234-237. |
null | 王美琪,杨建英,孙永康,等,2020.废弃矿山植被覆盖度无人机遥感快速提取技术[J].中国水土保持科学,18(2):130-139. |
null | 位振亚,罗仙平,梁健,等,2018.南方稀土矿山废弃地生态修复技术进展[J].有色金属科学与工程,9(4):102-106. |
null | 吴泽斌,吴立珺,卢经红,等,2018.赣南废弃稀土矿山生态修复公众参与意愿与影响因素研究[J].江西理工大学报,39(4):47-51. |
null | 邢宝君,唐水清,李乃文,等,2017.ISM耦合ANP矿工安全注意力衰减影响因素模型[J].中国安全生产科学技术,13(9):163-168. |
null | 许礼刚,王妤歆,关景文,2019.产业链安全视阈的稀土资源开发负外部性反哺机制研究[J].黄金科学技术,27(4):609-620. |
null | 徐水太,2014.赣州稀土产业可持续发展的问题与对策研究[J].江西理工大学学报,35(4):47-51. |
null | 徐水太,项宇,刘中亚,2016.离子型稀土原地浸矿地下水氨氮污染模拟与预测[J].有色金属科学与工程,7(2):140-146. |
null | 徐水太,张汗青,徐晨晨,等,2018.基于PSR模型的离子型稀土矿区生态安全评价研究[J].科技管理研究,(15):263-267. |
null | 于扬,王登红,田兆雪,等,2017.稀土矿区环境调查SMAIMA方法体系、评价模型及其应用——以赣南离子吸附型稀土矿山为例[J].地球学报,38(3):335-344. |
null | 郑先坤,冯秀娟,陈哲,等,2019.离子型稀土矿开采环境问题及废弃地修复治理研究进展[J].应用化工,48(3):681-684. |
/
〈 | 〉 |