收稿日期: 2020-06-24
修回日期: 2020-11-20
网络出版日期: 2021-03-22
Comprehensive Safety Evaluation of Huangjindong Tailing Pond Based on Improved Entropy Weight Method-Unascertained Measure Model
Received date: 2020-06-24
Revised date: 2020-11-20
Online published: 2021-03-22
针对尾矿库安全评价中存在的不确定性问题,以黄金洞尾矿库为例,引入未确知测度理论,分析评价对象与评价指标之间的关系,建立一个包含5个影响因素和18个影响因子的尾矿库综合安全指标评价体系,结合基于层次分析法—熵权法综合确定指标权重,构建基于改进熵权法—未确知测度模型。根据该模型的指标评价体系和分级模式确定指标测度函数,代入各指标实测值,得出多指标综合测度向量,并借助置信度识别准则准确判定尾矿库安全等级和各指标未确知测度重要度。结果表明:黄金洞尾矿库安全等级为Ⅱ级,尾矿库处于较安全状态。经比较,指标测度重要度从大到小为地基沉陷(B3)>洪水漫顶(B1)>安全管理(B4)>坝体溃坝(B2)>自然因素(B5),可知地基沉陷对尾矿库安全影响程度最大,应加强对地基沉陷的管理。基于改进熵权法—未确知测度模型得到的评价结果与实际结果相吻合,为尾矿库安全性评价提供了一种可行的方法。
石勇 , 史秀志 , 丁文智 . 基于改进熵权法—未确知测度模型的黄金洞尾矿库综合安全评价[J]. 黄金科学技术, 2021 , 29(1) : 155 -163 . DOI: 10.11872/j.issn.1005-2518.2021.01.115
In recent years,the state has strict requirements on the safety production of mining enterprises.The safety problem has become one of the most important problems of each mining enterprise.Tailings pond is an indispensable part in the production process of mining enterprises,so the safety of tailing pond is closely connected with the local development.The dam break of tailing pond will cause great loss and serious damage to local environment and economic development,and even endanger people’s lives.By evaluating the safety of tailings pond reasonably,the safety accident of tailings pond can be avoided effectively,so as to ensure the normal safety production of mining enterprises.The evaluation of tailings ponds is characterized by uncertainty,complexity and variability,and there are many indexes factors affecting the safety of tailings ponds.The information conveyed by most of the influencing factors is of significant uncertainty and randomness,which makes the safety evaluation of tailings ponds a complex and changeable problem filled with many uncertain factors.Aiming at the problem of uncertainty in safety evaluation of tailings pond,the theory of unascertained measure was introduced to analyze the relationship between the evaluation object and the evaluation indexes.Taking the Huangjindong tailings pond as an example,by selecting 18 influencing factors,a comprehensive safety index evaluation system of tailings pond containing 5 types of influencing factors and 18 influencing factors was established.The comprehensive weight of indexes was determined by combining the analytic hierarchy process(AHP)-entropy weight method,and an unascertained measure model based on the improved entropy weight method was constructed.By quantifying qualitative factors,this model eliminates the differences among factors,improves the problem that the subjective and objective weights have small differences and cause the evaluation results to change greatly,and weakens the influence of weight values on the evaluation results.At the same time,the index measure function is determined according to the index evaluation system and classification mode of the model,and the measured value of each index is substituted into it to obtain the comprehensive measure vector of multiple indexes,and the safety level of tailings pond and the importance of unascertained measure of each index are accurately determined by the confidence recognition criterion.Results show that the security level of Huangjindong gold tailings is Ⅱ level,means the tailings is in a safe state.By comparing,the importance level of indicator measure from high to low is foundation subsidence(B3),flood top(B1),safety management(B4),dam break(B2),natural factor(B5).That means foundation subsidence has the greatest impact on the safety of tailing pond,it is necessary to strengthen management of ground subsidence.The evaluation results based on the improved entropy weight method-unascertained measure model are consistent with the actual results,which provides a feasible method for the safety evaluation of tailings pond.
null | Chaurasia R C,Nikkam S,2016.A suitable process for clean coal recovery from tailing pond deposits[J].Energy Sources Part A—Recovery Utilization and Environmental Effects,38(23):3435-3439. |
null | Chen Xiangping,2018.Spectral HS projection algorithm for solving nonlinear monotone equations[J].Operations Research Transactions,22(3):15-27. |
null | Deng Hongwei,Hu Pulun,Yang Niange,al et,2012.Mining method choice based on empowerment combination TOPSIS[J].Journal of Guangxi University(Natural Science Edition),37(5):990-996. |
null | Gao Wei,Zhang Qingpu,Xiaobiao Dun,al et,2016.Comprehensive assessment of advanced military aerospace technologies based on improved EAHP and dynamic weighting[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,38(1):102-109. |
null | Guo Jinwei,Pu Xuqiang,Gao Xiang,al et,2014.Improved method on weights determination of indexes in multi-objective decision[J].Journal of Xidian University,41(6):118-125. |
null | Jiang Zhou,Huang Yanhua,Liu Fangqiu,al et,2016.Safety evaluation of tailings dams based on extension theory[J].Environmental Engineering,34(7):165-170. |
null | Khademi H,Abbaspour A,Martinez S, al et,2018.Provenance and environmental risk of windblown materials from mine tailing ponds,Murcia,Spain[J].Environmental Pollution,241:432-440. |
null | Li Fengjuan,Zhang Guang,Liu Mingze,al et,2019.Risk assessment of gold cave tailings reservoir based on variable weight synthesizing weights[J].China Mining Magazine,28(1):115-121. |
null | Liang Li,Liu Qi,Li Ming,2017.Dam-break risk assessment model of tailings reservoir based on variable weight synthesis and analytic hierarchy process[J].Journal of Northeastern University (Nature Science),38(12):1790-1794. |
null | Rao Yunzhang,Hou Yunbing,Pan Jianping,al et,2003.Study on neural network prediction of wastewater of tailings reservoir of a copper-iron mine[J].Metal Mine,(11):49-51,63. |
null | Tan Qinwen,Xin Baoquan,Wan Lu,al et,2018.Risk evaluation indexes and gradation method of major hazard installations for tailings pond[J].Journal of Safety Science and Technology,14(7):99-106. |
null | Wang Shi,Shi Yong,Wang Wanyin,2019.Comprehensive safety evaluation of tailings reservoir based on fuzzy multivariate contact model[J].Gold Science and Technology,27(6):903-911. |
null | Wang Ximei,Chen Jianhong,Yang Shan,2018.Study on uncertainty in safety evaluation of tailing ponds based on granular computing[J].Journal of Safety Science and Technology,14(1):42-48. |
null | Wang Xinmin,Wang Shi,Yan Debo,al et,2012.Risk assessment on blocking of filling pipeline based on uncertainty measurement theory[J].China Safety Science Journal,22(4):151-156. |
null | Wang Xuan,Wang Yabian,Liu Lichen,al et,2019.Analysis on environmental safety status and discussion on reasonable closure measures for tailings reservoir in Longnan City[J].Gold Science and Technology,27(1):144-152. |
null | Wang Yingbo,Wang Lin,Li Zhongxue,2012.Safety evaluation of mine tailings facilities based on HS-BP algorithm[J].Systems Engineering—Theory & Practice,32(11):2585-2590. |
null | Wu Deming,Yang Shan,Wang Ximei,2018.An improved evaluation method for safety harmony equation of tailing ponds[J].Gold Science and Technology,26(5):662-668. |
null | Xu Zhenkai,Liu Xuan,Wei Bowen,al et,2016.Tailings dam risk fuzzy evaluation model based on the cloud model[J].South-to-North Water Transfers and Water Science & Technology,14(6):122-127. |
null | Yang Yuping,Deng Xingxing,Feng Yan,2014.Optimization of mining method based on uncertainty measurement theory and AHP[J].Journal of Central South University (Science and Technology),45(11):3936-3942. |
null | Yu Guangming,Song Chuanwang,Pan Yongzhan,al et,2014.Review of new progress in tailing dam safety in foreign research and current state with development trent in China[J].Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering,33(Supp.1):3238-3248. |
null | 陈香萍,2018.谱HS投影算法求解非线性单调方程组[J].运筹学学报,22(3):15-27. |
null | 邓红卫,胡普仑,杨念哥,等,2012.基于组合赋权TOPSIS的采矿方法优选[J].广西大学学报(自然科学版),37(5):990-996. |
null | 高炜,张庆普,敦晓彪,等,2016.基于改进的可拓层次分析法和动态加权的航天高技术综合评价研究[J].系统工程与电子技术,38(1):102-109. |
null | 郭金维,蒲绪强,高祥,等,2014.一种改进的多目标决策指标权重计算方法[J].西安电子科技大学学报,41(6):118-125. |
null | 姜洲,黄艳华,刘方求,等,2016.基于可拓学的尾矿库安全评价[J].环境工程,34(7):165-170. |
null | 李凤娟,章光,刘明泽,等,2019.基于变权综合权重的黄金洞尾矿库风险评价[J].中国矿业,28(1):115-121. |
null | 梁力,刘奇,李明,2017.基于变权综合层次分析法的尾矿库溃坝风险模型[J].东北大学学报(自然科学版),38(12):1790-1794. |
null | 饶运章,侯运炳,潘建平,等,2003.某铜铁矿尾矿库废水神经网络预测研究[J].金属矿山,(11):49-51,63. |
null | 谭钦文,辛保泉,万露,等,2018.尾矿库重大危险源风险评价指标及分级方法[J].中国安全生产科学技术,14(7):99-106. |
null | 王石,石勇,王万银,2019.基于模糊多元联系度模型的尾矿库综合安全评价[J].黄金科学技术,27(6):903-911. |
null | 王喜梅,陈建宏,杨珊,2018.基于粒计算的尾矿库安全评价不确定性研究[J].中国安全生产科学技术,14(1):42-48. |
null | 王新民,王石,鄢德波,等,2012.基于未确知测度理论的充填管道堵塞风险性评价[J].中国安全科学学报,22(4):151-156. |
null | 王旋,王亚变,刘理臣,等,2019.陇南市尾矿库环境安全现状分析及合理闭库措施探讨[J].黄金科学技术,27(1):144-152. |
null | 王英博,王琳,李仲学,2012.基于HS-BP算法的尾矿库安全评价[J].系统工程理论与实践,32(11):2585-2590. |
null | 吴德明,杨珊,王喜梅,2018.一种改进的尾矿库安全和谐度方程评价方法[J].黄金科学技术,26(5):662-668. |
null | 徐镇凯,刘璇,魏博文,等,2016.基于云模型的尾矿库溃坝风险模糊评价模型[J].南水北调与水利科技,14(6):122-127. |
null | 阳雨平,邓星星,冯岩,2014.基于未确知测度与层次分析法的采矿方法优选[J].中南大学学报(自然科学版),45(11):3936-3942. |
null | 于广明,宋传旺,潘永战,等,2014.尾矿坝安全研究的国外新进展及我国的现状和发展态势[J].岩石力学与工程学报,33(增1):3238-3248. |
/
〈 |
|
〉 |